We audit other companies for a living. It would be indefensible not to have our own controls examined by someone who does not work here.
The auditor expressed an unqualified opinion on all five control areas examined, with three recommendations, all accepted by management.
Engagement letter, auditor identity and independence confirmation are restated in this prototype as placeholders.
The engagement covers the controls that underpin the credibility of our output — not the commercial performance of the business. Five areas were examined:
Scope limitation: the auditor tested controls and a sample of files. It did not re-perform every verification issued in the period, and this report is not an assurance over any individual supplier's status.
"In our opinion, the controls examined were designed appropriately and operated effectively throughout the period covered. We identified no instance of supplier-side revenue, no undeclared conflict affecting an issued report, and no failure of the two-person review requirement within the sample tested."
Three recommendations were issued, none of which affected the opinion. All three were accepted by management and are described below with their implementation status.
| Control area | Tests performed | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue separation | 100% of revenue transactions tested for counterparty type; supplier-register matching performed | No exceptions |
| Conflict register | All staff declarations tested; recusal evidence examined for the 2 declared conflicts | No exceptions |
| Report quality | 62 files sampled across all tiers; evidence grades, footnotes and reviewer sign-off re-performed | No exceptions |
| Information security | Access review, retention schedule, encryption at rest and in transit, disposal log | 1 recommendation |
| Data handling | Subject-access requests, lawful-basis records, transfer mechanisms | 2 recommendations |
Evidence packs for 14 closed files were retained beyond the published retention window. No data subject was affected and the material was securely deleted. Implemented
Two categories of buyer contact data lacked a recorded lawful basis at the point of collection. The basis has now been recorded in the intake form and the register. Implemented
Cross-border transfer records were held informally. A formal transfer register is now maintained and is subject to annual review. Implemented
We accept all three recommendations. Two concerned process documentation rather than outcomes; one concerned retention discipline. None involved a report issued to a buyer, and none involved supplier-side revenue or an undeclared conflict.
We have asked the auditor to re-test all three areas in the next engagement and to report the result whether or not it is favourable.
Appointed by the board, reports to the board, and is removable only by the board — not by management.
The auditor provides no consulting, tax or advisory services to Business Verify. Fee independence is disclosed annually.
Engagement partner rotates every five years. The current partner is in year two.
Unrestricted access to records, systems and personnel, including the ability to speak to any employee without management present.
The auditor's name, engagement letter and fee disclosure are withheld in this prototype pending confirmation of the appointed firm.
Separately from the external engagement, every member of staff re-attested compliance with the Independence Charter.
The operational detail — volumes, refusals, appeals and corrections — is in the transparency report.